ONLY GIRL ON THE JOBSITE™

By Renée Biery

listen on apple

listen on spotify

listen on amazon

Featured on this episode:

What you will learn from this episode:

  • How a detailed scope of work helps you identify additional construction management responsibilities before they affect your profitability.
  • Why construction management fees should reflect project complexity, team experience, and actual time requirements rather than a standard formula.
  • How to recognize unbilled hours and keep procurement income separate from construction management profitability.

Last week, we talked about why you can’t price a project you don’t fully understand.

But there’s another part of that conversation we need to address. Even when you understand a project going in, construction has a way of revealing things you couldn’t have anticipated.

Unexpected conditions. Additional decisions. More coordination. Responsibilities that require far more time than you originally estimated. And if you haven’t accounted for that work or established how you’ll handle it, you can spend months providing services you’re not adequately compensated for.

I know because I’ve lived it.

Today, I want to share a project that taught me some very expensive lessons about construction management fees, scope of work, and the difference between a project that looks profitable and one that actually is.

The Renovation That Changed How I Manage Projects

About seven years ago, a longtime client hired me to help renovate a beautiful old stone colonial. I’d worked with her for years on furnishings, so I knew her well. I understood her taste, her expectations, and the level of detail she wanted.

But this was an entirely different type of project.

The house dated back to the 1920s, and much of it hadn’t been updated in decades. The renovation included significant work throughout the main house, an addition, and improvements to other structures on the property.

I’d worked with the architect before, but I didn’t know the contractor.

And although the superintendent was talented, he was relatively early in his career for a project of this complexity.

At the time, I had a basic contract and an internal estimate of the hours I expected to spend. I shared that estimate with my client.

What I didn’t have was a formally documented scope of work that we’d reviewed together and she’d approved. That missing piece would become a very expensive lesson.

Unexpected Conditions Created More Construction Management Work

I love old houses. I grew up in one. But when you open up a house that hasn’t had significant renovations in decades, you’re going to find things nobody anticipated.

And we certainly did.

We discovered structural issues, water damage, poor insulation, and electrical work that had been patched together over the years.

There were plaster walls hiding problems nobody knew existed.

Then, when excavation began for the family room addition, the crew hit rock. Nobody knew it was there, and suddenly we had another problem to solve.

Every discovery created additional work. More conversations with contractors. More research. More decisions. More coordination.

And much of that work fell on me.

The pace of the project was frenetic from the beginning. Sometimes it became downright chaotic before settling back into frenetic again.

But the unexpected conditions were only part of the problem.

Scope Creep Doesn’t Always Look Like Scope Creep

While the house was revealing its problems, the scope of work was expanding.

My client added a scullery.

The third floor, which we’d initially discussed as something to explore, became an actual renovation. First, it was two rooms. Then it became four.

Other areas we thought we could preserve needed more work than anticipated.

And you know what happens when you open a wall. Suddenly, everyone starts asking what else we could do while we’re already there.

One decision leads to another. Before you know it, you’re managing a project that looks very different from the one you originally agreed to.

What began as a 12-to-14-month renovation became a 24-month project.

And because I had other projects happening simultaneously, those additional months affected my entire business.

Here’s what I’ve learned about scope creep.

It rarely happens all at once.

Each individual change can feel perfectly reasonable. It’s only when you look back at the entire project that you realize how far you’ve moved from the original plan.

Without a clearly documented scope of work, I didn’t have a reference point to identify those changes. So I kept absorbing the additional hours.

Your Construction Management Scope of Work Protects Your Fee

Looking back, I can see that two different problems were happening.

First, I underestimated some of the responsibilities I should have anticipated.

The home’s age, the complexity of the renovation, and the construction team’s experience level all affected how much time I needed to spend managing the project.

Second, the project itself changed.

Additional rooms, unexpected conditions, and new decisions created work that wasn’t part of the original plan.

Those are two different situations, and they require two different conversations.

One is about accurately understanding the work you’re agreeing to before establishing your construction management fee.

The other is about recognizing when the agreed-upon work changes.

A detailed, client-approved scope of work helps you distinguish between the two.

It doesn’t prevent unexpected conditions or additional requests. But it gives you something to reference when the project changes.

You can explain what was originally included, what has changed, and what those changes mean for your services and fees. Without that clarity, it’s far too easy to keep doing more work without addressing the additional compensation.

The Construction Team Affects Your Profitability

Here’s something else I didn’t adequately account for.

The time required to establish a working relationship with a new contractor.

Every construction team operates differently. You need to understand how they communicate, manage their jobsite, coordinate decisions, and handle problems. And when you haven’t worked together before, there’s a learning curve. That takes time.

On this particular project, the superintendent was talented and did good work. But he hadn’t managed a project with this level of complexity. That meant more involvement from me.

More presence on the jobsite. More follow-up. More support.

Today, I account for that time before establishing my construction management fees.

Working with a contractor I’ve known for ten years is very different from working with a company I’ve never heard of.

Both situations require evaluation, but they don’t necessarily require the same number of hours. And your fee needs to reflect that.

Why I Don’t Use a Formula for Construction Management Fees

I know some designers calculate construction management fees using a percentage of the construction budget. Others charge by square footage or use a flat fee per room.

I understand why. Those formulas are simple. They’re easy to explain, and they give you a starting point.

But I’ve tried them. And when I went back through my historical project data, I discovered they didn’t accurately reflect the time I actually spent. Here’s why:

A project’s square footage doesn’t tell you how complicated it will be to manage.

Neither does its construction budget.

A smaller renovation in an older house with complicated existing conditions, an unfamiliar contractor, and a client who needs constant guidance could require far more of your time than a larger project.

Meanwhile, that larger project might have straightforward conditions, a contractor you trust, and a client who makes decisions quickly.

Those two projects shouldn’t necessarily have comparable construction management fees.

Your fee needs to reflect the actual demands of the project.

That includes the complexity, existing conditions, construction team, client expectations, and the number of decisions you’re responsible for managing.

A formula can’t account for all those variables. And when the formula underestimates the work, you’re the one absorbing the difference.

Procurement Income Shouldn’t Cover Construction Management Losses

There’s another lesson from this project that I want to share because I think more designers experience this than they realize.

I handled a considerable amount of procurement on this renovation.

And the income from that procurement helped the project feel financially successful, even while I was accumulating unbilled construction management hours.

But that’s not how it should work.

Procurement and construction management are two separate income streams.

Each one needs to be profitable on its own.

When you use procurement income to compensate for construction management hours you didn’t bill, you’re hiding a problem.

I did that for years. It made projects appear more profitable than they actually were because I wasn’t capturing all the compensation I’d earned for my construction management services.

And if you’re a designer who doesn’t handle procurement, you don’t even have that additional income to offset the loss.

Your construction management fees need to support the construction management work. Your procurement income should remain procurement income.

When both parts of your business stand on their own, you have a much clearer understanding of your profitability.

What I Would Do Differently Today

I want to be clear about something. I would absolutely take that project again. It was a spectacular home, a wonderful client, and I’m incredibly proud of what we accomplished.

But I would approach the financial side very differently.

First, I would spend more time developing a detailed scope of work before the project began. I’d review it with my client and get her approval.

That wouldn’t prevent the third floor from expanding or the excavation crew from discovering rock. But it would give us a clear understanding of what we’d originally agreed to.

Second, I would account for the additional time required to work with an unfamiliar construction team. I’d build that time into my fee instead of discovering months later how much involvement the team needed.

Finally, I would address changes as they happened rather than quietly absorbing the additional work. Because there’s a big difference between choosing to give a client extra time and feeling obligated to give it because you never established how that time would be handled.

One is a business decision. The other can leave you feeling depleted.

Take a Closer Look at Your Construction Management Hours

Here’s what I’d encourage you to do.

Think about a construction project you’re managing right now. Look at the work you’ve performed over the past two weeks.

How much of that work did you anticipate when you established your fee?

How much surprised you?

And how much of that additional work is likely to continue throughout the remainder of the project?

Those questions can tell you a tremendous amount about your profitability.

Sometimes the reason you’re not making the money you expected has nothing to do with your hourly rate. It’s because you haven’t fully accounted for the work you’re doing. And the place to address that is at the beginning, before the project starts, while the scope of work is still being defined.

Your construction management fee should reflect the work you’re actually agreeing to perform, not simply the work you hope the project will require.

That’s a change you can make before you prepare your very next proposal.


Like this Episode?

Be sure to check out Episode #131: Building with Numbers: The Art of Pricing Construction Projects

Be sure to check out Episode #147: Pricing a Project: Best Practices with Lesley Myrick

Be sure to check out Episode #305: You Can’t Price a Project You Don’t Understand Yet

follow the podcast

want to be a guest?

Fill out the form on the inquiry page under the podcast tab and we'll get in touch with you!

leave us a review!

We love hearing from you about your thoughts on the podcast, you can leave a review on apple!

You can find us anywhere! Click the icons to find us on the podcast platform you use!